I guess I fall under the weird people that liked 7 and 8 more than 9.
Not saying much since I make love to every FF game I put my hands on.
To me, though, 9 felt a tad bit like Chrono Cross. They somewhat had similar designs and when I forged the first double-edge blade for Zidane, I was like "LOL Serge's weapon."
The story did not compel me forward. I just spent too much time and beat the game just to beat it.
X I beat for the story(and also making characters GODLIKE ...lol).
Then again, I play most rpgs to just see the limits they place on stats development.
I'm a number cruncher, what can I say?
7 is still my favorite FF game(X, Tactics, and Crisis Core come close). It's not because of,"OMG CLOUD! OOO SO EMO! I WUV U!" It was because of the gameplay and added stuff.
I really loved the entire materia setup with weapons and armor. Battle was alright but like every other FF game pretty much so meh. Chocobo raising/racing was lots of fun as was the battle area, various games in the Gold Saucer, and even Wutai.
But 9 wasn't bad or anything, I just place it at the top of my list for favorite rpgs of all time.
(Sorry, CT and CC rank higher than FF9.)