I think that the way things have been run is quite fine. .TaKaM has a lot of spriting experience and obviously has an eye for art in general. There isn't a specific "standard" or an example that someone can follow. It has to be something you know and something you can do well. You can't be taught how to judge art. There are only a few of really good spriters on this board that have already found the said talent and can consistently produce a very high level of artwork. Most others are still on the road to becoming that.. which is fine. However, any Average Joe cannot be held responsible for the judging of a style that will define a community. Sure, everyone should have some say, but in the end, it should be left up to the "experts."