I am a Christian, and I can tell you from a christian standpoint that this woman is a lunatic. She says it would be hypocritical to read the book, but that the fact that she pays taxes allows her to speak out against this book. Fair enough - but that applies to only books in generla. What would entitle her to speak out against a particular book? Knowledge of the book. She says she has "researched online", most likely reading book reviews and biased articles also objecting to the book's content. This in no way gives her any justifiable knowledge of the book itself - only select people's opinions on it. She says she would not have to read an entire porn mag to know that it was obscene. However, if somebody defamed a softcore pornography magazine or titillating advertisement in a way that made it sound obscene and she mistook it to be of worse content than it was, that would not be grounds for argument either.
Also, the fact that she suggests C.S. Lewis' "Chronicles of Narnia" series to replace it seems very, very hypocritical to me. It also contains witchcraft, magic, evil themes, witches, fantastical settings and actions, and nowhere does it promote Christianity. Christians simply jump to the conclusion that it does because it was written by a Christian author and it's story has a few parallels, mostly in the character fo Aslan, who appears to me and others to ahve been inspired by the character of Jesus Christ. But where, exactly, did Jesus fight off witches, lead gigantic wars, or make four children kings of the world?
Her argument is highly ludicrous, terribly biased, and absolutely uninformd. If the school board approves the removal, I will eprsonally send a protest letter, probably containing this post. This woman has no right to make these claims, based on what she herself has said.